Ruleside
Controversial callsGermany vs England
Germany vs England · FIFA World Cup 2010 — Round of 16

Lampard's ghost goal — ball clearly over the line

Correct decision
Goal stands
Goal — ball crossed the line by nearly a metre
Referee called
No goal — referee and linesman both failed to see the ball cross the line
Should have been
Goal — ball crossed the line by nearly a metre

What happened

In the 38th minute with Germany leading 2-1, Frank Lampard struck a shot that hit the underside of the crossbar and bounced down clearly behind the goal line — by approximately 60cm according to later measurements. Referee Jorge Larrionda and his linesman Mauricio Espinosa did not award the goal. England went in at half time 2-1 down instead of level at 2-2. Germany won the match 4-1. The incident caused worldwide outrage and FIFA accelerated the introduction of goal-line technology.

Why the law says so

The Laws of the Game are clear — if the whole of the ball passes over the goal line between the goalposts and under the crossbar, a goal is scored. The ball clearly crossed the line. The referee made a clear and obvious error. This is precisely the category of mistake that VAR and goal-line technology were designed to prevent. Goal-line technology (GLT) was officially approved by IFAB in 2012 and introduced at the 2014 World Cup, directly as a result of incidents like this one.

Key factors

  • Ball crossed the line by approximately 60cm — not a marginal call
  • Visible to everyone in the stadium and on television instantly
  • Referee and linesman were both in poor positions
  • No goal-line technology in 2010 — introduced at 2014 World Cup partly because of this
  • Would be awarded instantly with modern goal-line technology
  • England went on to lose 4-1 — the disallowed goal could have changed the match
Law 10: A goal is scored when the whole of the ball passes over the goal line, between the goalposts and under the crossbar. This ball clearly satisfied all three conditions.
Walk through it yourself
See the exact referee logic step by step
Investigate →
Read the full VAR rule