Ruleside
Referee logic, step by step

Investigate a call

Answer questions one at a time, following the same logic referees use. Get a verdict with the exact IFAB law cited.

26 investigations

Penalty
Should that have been a penalty? A foul or a handball, and the area is taken as read.
Handball
Deliberate? Unnatural position? Does it matter for a goal?
Red card
Was that a sending-off? Violence, DOGSO, abuse, or a second caution.
Offside
Was the player in an offside position? Were they involved in play?
Yellow card
Was that a caution? Fouls, dissent, delaying, simulation, celebrations, and repeated offences.
Denied a goal or clear chance
DOGSO: the four factors, and why it is sometimes a yellow rather than a red.
Foul
The full ladder: was it a foul, careless, reckless or excessive force, and what does it cost?
VAR protocol
Should VAR have reviewed this at all? The monitor, who may ask for a review, and whether the protocol was followed.
Simulation
Was it a dive? The test is the attempt to deceive, not the contact.

Less common

Manager or bench
Warning, caution, sending-off: the separate ladder Law 12 runs for the technical area.
The referee: whistle, advantage, injuries
Why there was no whistle, why play carried on, when play stops for an injury, and when a decision can still be changed.
Misconduct
Cards away from a challenge: what was said, a delayed restart, leaving the field, a goal celebration, and the offences Law 12 names by name.
Taking a free kick
The wall, the ten yards, the quick kick, and what happens once the ball is in play.
Throw-in
Foul throw? The two metres, the five-second countdown, and the thrower's second touch.
Corner or goal kick
Who touched it last, how each kick is taken, and the new corner for the eight seconds.
Ball in and out of play
Was it out? The line that still counts as in, a burst ball, a broken crossbar, the referee getting hit, the dropped ball, and the kick-off.
Substitutions and extra persons
How many subs, the ten seconds, a goalkeeper change, and what happens when someone is on the field who should not be.
Goals and the shoot-out
What counts as a goal, how a drawn match is decided, and the shoot-out: who is eligible, why numbers are equalised, and when a kick is a miss rather than a retake.
Added time and the length of the match
What the referee has to allow for, why the board is a minimum rather than a countdown, and what happens to a match that is abandoned.
Kit and equipment
Jewellery, undershirts, head covers, slogans: what a player may and may not wear.
Sin bins
Temporary dismissals: where they are allowed, how long, and why the system changes what a second caution does.
Goalkeeper
Eight seconds, back-passes, handling: what may a goalkeeper do?
Taking a penalty kick
Who moved early, the wrong kicker, feinting, the second touch, and whether the kick is retaken.
Captain, concussion and other protocols
Who may approach the referee, the ten seconds, the minute off the field, the concussion substitution, and whether a rule you saw is actually in the Laws.
Off-the-ball offences
Holding at a corner, blocking without contact, a high foot, something said, an object thrown, or an offence off the field: what it costs and where the free kick is taken from.
Linesman or fourth official
What a flag means, why it stayed down for a foul, who decides added time, and when the referee can overrule an official.